Comments on: Maqasid on “Blogging the Quran: A Letter to Ziauddin Sardar” http://mtakbar.wordpress.com/2008/01/16/maqasid-on-blogging-the-quran-a-letter-to-ziauddin-sardar/ "The heart has its reasons which reason knows not of." Sun, 11 Oct 2009 13:16:12 +0000 http://wordpress.com/ hourly 1 By: maulana munir hassan (south africa) http://mtakbar.wordpress.com/2008/01/16/maqasid-on-blogging-the-quran-a-letter-to-ziauddin-sardar/#comment-282 maulana munir hassan (south africa) Fri, 07 Mar 2008 14:12:24 +0000 http://mtakbar.wordpress.com/2008/01/16/maqasid-on-blogging-the-quran-a-letter-to-ziauddin-sardar/#comment-282 Abdullah hasan builds an apartheid wall between the umma and the quran, and "burns" the quran. Nabi muhammad through the quran addresses muslims, christians, jews, athiests... muslims champion the quran, transgenerationally we receive certain readings of the quran - we have every rught to brutally interigate these readings. Sooyooti in his tafsiir is faulted by scholars, there are allegations that sooyooti was politically an alawi... interpretation should not be elitized, yes expertise does have its advantages. for example here in south africa very learned lawyers crfafted racist law and very learned judges expanded this law through the courts - this shows that expertise does not gaurantee correctness. with regards to Sooyooti's knowledges(pl) the question is "so what and what next" at times in the world of classical tafsiir one gets the feeling of ad nauseam repetition, one actually gets sick. what about Ibnu taymiyua's take on Razi - Abdullah hasan builds an apartheid wall between the umma and the quran, and “burns” the quran. Nabi muhammad through the quran addresses muslims, christians, jews, athiests…
muslims champion the quran, transgenerationally we receive certain readings of the quran – we have every rught to brutally interigate these readings.
Sooyooti in his tafsiir is faulted by scholars, there are allegations that sooyooti was politically an alawi…
interpretation should not be elitized, yes expertise does have its advantages.
for example here in south africa very learned lawyers crfafted racist law and very learned judges expanded this law through the courts – this shows that expertise does not gaurantee correctness.
with regards to Sooyooti’s knowledges(pl) the question is “so what and what next”
at times in the world of classical tafsiir one gets the feeling of ad nauseam repetition, one actually gets sick.
what about Ibnu taymiyua’s take on Razi -

]]> By: mtakbar http://mtakbar.wordpress.com/2008/01/16/maqasid-on-blogging-the-quran-a-letter-to-ziauddin-sardar/#comment-192 mtakbar Fri, 01 Feb 2008 17:56:31 +0000 http://mtakbar.wordpress.com/2008/01/16/maqasid-on-blogging-the-quran-a-letter-to-ziauddin-sardar/#comment-192 Rafay, Welcome. Yes the media does a spectacular job in degrading the level of discussion and dialogue and all too often focus on these out of wack, unorthodx Muslims to give the view point of Islam. Rafay,
Welcome. Yes the media does a spectacular job in degrading the level of discussion and dialogue and all too often focus on these out of wack, unorthodx Muslims to give the view point of Islam.

]]> By: Rafay Kashmiri http://mtakbar.wordpress.com/2008/01/16/maqasid-on-blogging-the-quran-a-letter-to-ziauddin-sardar/#comment-181 Rafay Kashmiri Wed, 23 Jan 2008 18:31:58 +0000 http://mtakbar.wordpress.com/2008/01/16/maqasid-on-blogging-the-quran-a-letter-to-ziauddin-sardar/#comment-181 Media's clients @ Its interesting the Medias give special attention to the Charlatans, anything that insults and degrades Islam is welcomed by these retarded media "intellectuals" geneticaly abused. Media’s clients

@ Its interesting the Medias give
special attention to the Charlatans, anything
that insults and degrades Islam is welcomed by
these retarded media “intellectuals” geneticaly
abused.

]]> By: Ijtema » Blog Archive » A Letter to Ziauddin Sarda, from ‘Blogging the Qur’an’ Guardian http://mtakbar.wordpress.com/2008/01/16/maqasid-on-blogging-the-quran-a-letter-to-ziauddin-sardar/#comment-165 Ijtema » Blog Archive » A Letter to Ziauddin Sarda, from ‘Blogging the Qur’an’ Guardian Thu, 17 Jan 2008 21:12:59 +0000 http://mtakbar.wordpress.com/2008/01/16/maqasid-on-blogging-the-quran-a-letter-to-ziauddin-sardar/#comment-165 [...] Found via MT. Akbar. [...] [...] Found via MT. Akbar. [...]

]]>